EXCHANGE RATES (MIDDLE RATES)
US DOLLAR: RS. 332.60 UK POUND: RS. 445.68 EURO: RS. 371.88 JAPANESE YEN: RS. 2.10 INDIAN RUPEE: RS. 3.50 AUSTRALIAN DOLLAR: RS. 232.68
MANAGEMENT DIGEST

LEARNING TODAY

THE FRICTION OF LEARNING

Manilka Ediriweera rues the impact of artificial intelligence on learning

The role of AI in academia has been under intense scrutiny for a while. Like it or not, artificial intelligence is marking a profound shift in how we learn, research and acquire knowledge. While many conversations centre on academic dishonesty, reducing the debate to that alone is like judging a book by its cover. 

While academic integrity in the era of AI is a legitimate concern, a growing body of research suggests that the larger question is what happens to the brain when the friction of the learning process disappears. 

So what happens when artificial intelligence removes that friction through which we learn? 

The struggle of writing a half-baked thesis statement, only to try again, hashing and rehashing arguments and solutions when they refuse to come together or combing through papers one after another in the hope that one of them will answer your questions. 

Such friction is how we learn. 

After all, we don’t learn by simply arriving at an answer. The process of doing so through reasoning, writing, tackling confusion and revising is how we learn. Removing the friction is like waiting to grow stronger while a machine lifts your weights for you.

A study titled Your Brain on ChatGPT carried out by MIT Media Lab tracked brain activity in students writing essays with and without AI assistance. It found weaker neural connectivity among those who relied on large language models (LLMs) than others who didn’t use tools. 

Other studies have also found that AI users showed reduced brain engagement, weaker memory recall and a decline in critical thinking. 

None of this is entirely new as calculators, spellcheck tools and the internet all generated the same anxieties. What’s different this time is the nature of the tool itself and what we are offloading. 

This time around, artificial intelligence is generating, interpreting and participating in knowledge production itself. 

It’s also important to remember that LLMs such as ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude are part of the ecosystem. 

At one end, you have basic tools such as citation generators and grammar checkers that fast track repetitive tasks. Then there are writing assistants that draft papers and structure assignments based on inputs. And advanced autonomous agents that can execute entire stages of a research process with minimal human intervention also exist.

Students are also growing increasingly dependent on AI, to the point of complete disengagement from cognitive work. Researchers too are using it to navigate literature, analyse data and accelerate parts of the research process, and making the line between assistance and outsourcing thinner in both cases.

Some universities and institutions are moving towards bans and restrictions while others are integrating artificial intelligence directly into coursework by redesigning assessments. 

What’s worth remembering is that universities aren’t simply factories for producing degrees and research papers. While it may seem so at times, given how mechanical the process can be, they’re places where people learn to think, question and reason for themselves. 

French philosophers Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari offer an interesting lens for what’s actually at stake here. 

At its core, their argument is that genuine thinking and writing are acts of production. They produce something that didn’t exist before – whether it is a new question, way of seeing a problem or an argument. 

While AI can engage in processes that resemble that kind of thinking, it works by drawing on patterns in the vast amounts of data in which it has been trained. 

What it can do is synthesise, rearrange and extend what already exists. What it can’t do (at least, not yet!) is draw on lived experiences, intellectual struggles, moral reasoning or the personal judgement that comes with grappling with a problem yourself. 

AI can provide similar answers because it draws from overlapping bodies of human knowledge and recombining what has already been written into something that feels new. As of now, the processes are only recursive. 

This begs the question whether AI is transforming academia or unravelling the very practices upon which it is built. 

The honest answer is that it can do both, depending on how it’s used. The complication here is that ignoring artificial intelligence is not an option. Used properly, it can be a helpful tool. However, its unstructured and unsupervised use is producing the decline. 

So instead of camping out on either side of the ‘AI is good or bad’ debate, it’s time to acknowledge that it can enhance learning but also hinder it. 

Where academia will end up will depend on how we engage with artificial intelligence. That’s the choice that learning institutions must make, to nurture people who think rather than prompt. 

Universities aren’t simply factories

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Back to top button
Desktop Popup ImageMobile Popup Image×