EXCHANGE RATES (MIDDLE RATES)
US DOLLAR: RS. 332.60 UK POUND: RS. 445.68 EURO: RS. 371.88 JAPANESE YEN: RS. 2.10 INDIAN RUPEE: RS. 3.50 AUSTRALIAN DOLLAR: RS. 232.68
MANAGEMENT DIGEST

CORPORATE CONTRITION

AN APOLOGY MADE EASY!

When ‘sorry’ seems to be the hardest word

BY Jayashantha Jayawardhana

When it was disclosed in 2014 that Facebook (FB) had allowed academic researchers to manipulate the newsfeeds of some 689,000 users over a week in 2012, there was massive public outrage. The experiment – where half these users saw fewer positive posts than usual and the other half saw fewer negative ones than usual – was designed to determine whether the changes would cause people to write more positive or negative posts themselves. 

Researchers did discover evidence of ‘emotional contagion’ and go on to publish their results in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS). But their findings were eclipsed by the public outcry.

The Washington Post called it “creepy” and The Atlantic said that it might have been illegal. One privacy advocate wondered whether it could have made people suicidal. 

Shortly after the disclosure, lead researcher Dr. Adam Kramer issued a statement apologising for the anxiety that the experiment had caused. However, FB continued to defend its actions for days, arguing that the boilerplate language in its 9,000 word user agreement constituted informed consent. 

Subsequently, Facebook’s Chief Operating Officer Sheryl Sandberg offered a half-hearted apology for poor communication about the study. 

Three months later, its Chief Technology Officer Mike Schroepfer claimed that Facebook had been unprepared for the reaction. He admitted that there were things FB should have done differently and articulated new research guidelines. But he didn’t apolo­gise. 

Facebook blundered by violating users’ trust and then compounded the problem with an evasive, awkward, three step and almost remorseless apology.

Unfortunately, many enterprises follow the same treacherous path. 

At some point, every entity makes a mistake that necessitates an apology to an individual, a group of customers, employees, business partners or the public. And more often than not, its leaders fail to apologise effectively. 

This can place relationships with stakeholders at risk and damage reputations irreparably – especially if the incidents are publicised.

So why do we hesitate to apologise, both as individuals and organisations? 

Maurice Schweitzer, Alison Wood Brooks and Adam Galinsky co-authored an illuminating article titled The Organisational Apo­logy in the Harvard Business Review (HBR), and threw light on the apology dilemma. 

“First, we are psychologically predisposed to finding reasons (or excuses) to delay or avoid saying we’re sorry,” they wrote.

The coauthors continued: “Apologising feels uncomfortable and risky. There’s a loss of power or face involved – it rearranges the status hierarchy and makes us beholden, at least temporarily, to the other party. That doesn’t feel good. So it’s no wonder people try to avoid dwelling on or drawing attention to mistakes; and when one is pointed out, they get defensive, arguing their side of the story and shifting blame to others.”

Apologies are no less difficult for organisations. 

When considering whether and how to apologise, even seasoned leaders can become gripped by indecision. A corporate mistake is often made by a single division or employee, and a bad situation is frequently made worse by events outside organisational control. 

Companies also have a strong tendency to always view the situation through a legal lens. 

Corporate counsel may fixate on whether any laws were violated and warn managers that an apology might be construed as an admission of liability (possibly exposing the company to litigation) rather than an effort to empathise with the offended party. 

Although effective apologies address the recipients’ feeling and don’t prove a point, this litigious perspective has become increasingly ingrained in many organisations. 

“Companies need to stop thinking this way. Most apologies are low cost – and many create substantial value. They can help defuse a tense situation and fears of litigation are often unfounded,” the writers assert.  

Therefore, businesses need lucid, unambiguous guidelines for determining whether a misstep merits an apology – and when it does, for composing and delivering an effective message. 

Four questions help establish whether an apology is necessary. Was there a violation, real or perceived? Was the violation core or noncritical to the company’s mission? How will the public react? And is the company willing to commit to change? 

Once an organisation has decided that it should apologise, it needs to think carefully about where, when and how an apology should be made on behalf of the company; the substance of it, as it must reflect candour, remorse and commitment to change; how far and wide should it reach; how soon should it be delivered; how should it be crafted; and to whom it should appeal.

Related Articles

Check Also
Close
Back to top button
Desktop Popup ImageMobile Popup Image×