Do You Give Employees a Reason to Feel Proud of What They Do?
I recently visited Wake Forest University, in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, where I serve on the College Board of Visitors. The campus was buzzing — in part because the weather was so nice, in part because the football team had cracked the national Top 25. But much of the warm feeling was the afterglow of a recently completed, larger-than-life dance extravaganza starring the school’s facilities-and-maintenance staff.
You read that right. For three nights, nearly 70 custodians, landscapers, electricians, and construction crews performed in the school’s main Quad, where thousands of students, faculty, alumni, and neighbors roared their approval. Think Cirque du Soleil, but with lawn mowers, trucks, ladders, brooms, hammers, and drills. The show, called “From the Ground Up,” was as colorful as it was unusual: Folks who do some of the least glamorous work (and least visible) on campus showcased their skills, creativity, and humor to the delight of the community.
They also showcased their pride in what they do — which was really, I believe, the importance of the shows for them, and the enduring lesson of their performance for organizations in all sorts of fields. Everywhere you look, the competitive environment is more demanding than ever, which means that people at every level, and especially those on the front lines, have to be at their best, their most determined, every day. There’s no doubt that giving people raises can up their game, and I’m all for it. But I’m convinced that if you truly want people to elevate their performance, you first have to build up their pride. It’s much more likely that people will do things in exceptional ways if they believe deeply in what they do.
Jon R. Katzenbach, the influential management consultant, made this case in a book whose title summarizes its core message — Why Pride Matters More Than Money. Katzenbach argues that pride grows out of “the relentless pursuit of worthwhile endeavors.” This “intrinsic pride” becomes “institution-building” when it “prompts the kind of effective, customer-focused behaviors” that distinguish an organization from its rivals. Commitment based on “self-serving or materialistic gains,” he adds, is “short-term, transient, and risky.” It doesn’t unleash “the kind of emotional commitment” that builds “long-term sustainability.”
Many of Katzenbach’s examples involve elite performers such as McKinsey consultants and Microsoft engineers. But pride may be most powerful, and it is certainly most memorable, when it is embraced by frontline employees who rarely spend time in the spotlight.
A few years back, for example, I studied the customer-service transformation at Mercedes-Benz USA, the sales-and-service arm of the German automaker. Leadership could not understand why the client experience at its dealerships seemed so unremarkable even though the cars themselves were so extraordinary. They had plenty of policies, practices, and financial incentives for frontline employees. The problem, as one senior leader told me, was that “pride in the brand was not quite as strong as we thought, the level of engagement with the work not as deep as we thought.” Dealers could train more, and even pay more, but until frontline people genuinely cared more, it was hard for them to serve customers with an authentic sense of connection.
So Mercedes devised a creative set of grassroots initiatives to instill pride and incite passion. For example, it invited more than 20,000 frontline employees, the vast majority of whom had never driven a Mercedes vehicle outside the dealership lot, to spend 48 hours with a model of their choice, to get a feel for not just how the cars perform, but how they can turn heads when you pull into a church parking lot or high-school football game. The company also built a Brand Immersion Center at its huge manufacturing complex near Birmingham, Alabama, where thousands of employees will visit to, well, get immersed in the history of Mercedes-Benz and see for themselves how the cars are built.”Once folks see the levels of excellence we achieve to produce these cars,” a Mercedes executive told me, “they’ll understand that it’s our obligation to create a customer experience on par with that.”
I witnessed a similar phenomenon when I studied the high-performance culture at Davita, a company that has delivered impressive results in in a brutally tough business — providing dialysis treatments to 200,000 patients with kidney disease. Longtime CEO Kent Thiry, who recently stepped down from his day-to-day role, describes Davita as “a community first and a company second.” If the organization’s 55,000 people can figure out how to take care of each other, he told me, they will naturally take care of patients, and the business will take care of itself. So life at DaVita is filled with symbols, traditions, even songs, that bear little resemblance to life inside conventional organizations — all of which are designed to instill a spirit of belonging and a sense of pride. Thiry likes to cite that familiar aphorism, “One cannot pour from an empty cup.” Translation: If you expect people to give exceptional performance every day, especially in hard and unglamorous jobs, make sure they have a reason to believe.
As it turns out, the extravaganza at Wake Forest was not a one-of-a-kind performance. It was organized and choreographed by an outfit called Forlklift Dance Works, based in Austin, Texas. Forklift has worked with sanitation workers in Austin to create “Trash Dance,” with food-service workers at Williams College to perform “Served,” and with frontline people in all sorts of other everyday settings.
So by all means, give your people a raise and some perks. But also give them opportunities to build up their pride — and maybe even a chance to dance.